Two affordable cordless stick vacuums compete for household dominance. The BLACK+DECKER offers budget-friendly convenience with extended runtime, while the Eureka RapidClean Pro delivers stronger suction and motorized cleaning power. Here's our detailed breakdown.
| Specification | BLACK+DECKER Carpet Sweeper 50 Minute Lithium | Eureka RapidClean Pro Cordless Vacuum 🏆 Winner 🏆 |
|---|---|---|
| Suction Power | — | 250W Brushless Motor |
| Battery Life | — | 50 minutes |
| Bin Capacity | 0.5 liters | 0.6 liters |
| Noise Level | — | 78 dB |
| Weight | 3.5 lbs | 5.1 lbs |
| Self Emptying | No | — |
| Product | BLACK+DECKER Carpet Sweeper 50 Minute Lithium Floor Sweeper, Multi-Surface Use, Easy One Hand Cleaning, Self Standing, Charger Included (HFS115J10) | — |
| Manufacturer | BLACK+DECKER | — |
| Series Model | HFS115J10 | — |
| Battery Type | Lithium-ion | — |
| Battery Life Min | 50 | — |
| Charging Time Min | 180 | — |
| Spot Cleaning | Yes | — |
| Standard Mode | Yes | — |
| Mopping | No | — |
| Scheduling | No | — |
| App Control | No | — |
| Dirt Detect | No | — |
| Hepa Filter | No | — |
| Voice Control | — | |
| Wifi Connected | No | — |
| Anti Tangle Brush | Yes | — |
| Obstacle Avoidance | No | — |
| Tile | Yes | — |
| Vinyl | Yes | — |
| Hardwood | Yes | — |
| Laminate | Yes | — |
| Pet Hair | Yes | — |
| Allergens | No | — |
| Fine Dust | Yes | — |
| Large Debris | Yes | — |
| Carpet Low Pile | Yes | — |
| Carpet High Pile | No | — |
| Carpet Medium Pile | Yes | — |
| Attachments | — | Crevice Tool, Dusting Brush |
| Charging Time | — | 4 hours |
Eureka RapidClean Pro Cordless Vacuum
Our top pick for this comparison
The BLACK+DECKER Carpet Sweeper and Eureka RapidClean Pro represent two different approaches to cordless cleaning at the budget-friendly end of the market. The BLACK+DECKER positions itself as an ultra-lightweight, extended-runtime solution perfect for quick cleanups and maintenance between deeper cleanings. Its 50-minute battery life and 3.5-pound weight make it ideal for users who prioritize convenience and ease of use over raw cleaning power.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro, priced at $136.99 versus the BLACK+DECKER's $54.99, occupies a middle ground between budget models and premium cordless vacuums. With a 250W brushless motor, motorized brush tool, and LED headlight, it targets users willing to spend more for enhanced cleaning capabilities. The Eureka is heavier at 5.1 pounds but promises more thorough cleaning performance.
These products serve distinctly different customer needs. The BLACK+DECKER appeals to apartment dwellers, those with primarily hard floors, and budget-conscious consumers seeking a supplementary cleaning tool. The Eureka targets homeowners with mixed flooring, moderate pet hair concerns, and those seeking a primary stick vacuum solution without spending premium prices.
Both vacuums lack smart features, app control, and self-emptying technology, positioning them squarely in the practical, no-frills category. Neither offers the premium features found in $400+ models, but both deliver solid value for their respective price points and use cases.
The BLACK+DECKER Carpet Sweeper excels on hard floors and low-to-medium pile carpets, delivering consistent pickup of surface debris, dust, and pet hair. Its lightweight design allows for easy maneuvering around furniture and quick cleanups. However, the lack of specified suction power and motorized brush means it struggles with deep carpet cleaning and embedded pet hair. Users report it's excellent for daily maintenance but inadequate as a primary vacuum for homes with heavy foot traffic or multiple pets.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro's 250W brushless motor provides noticeably stronger suction compared to the BLACK+DECKER. The included motorized brush tool makes a significant difference on carpeted surfaces, actively agitating fibers to extract embedded dirt and pet hair that the BLACK+DECKER misses. Real-world testing shows the Eureka handles medium-to-high pile carpets more effectively and picks up pet hair more thoroughly in a single pass.
On hard floors, both vacuums perform adequately, though the Eureka's stronger suction provides faster debris collection. The BLACK+DECKER's lighter weight makes it slightly more maneuverable on hard surfaces, but the performance difference is minimal. For stairs, the BLACK+DECKER's 3.5-pound weight provides a significant advantage, allowing extended stair cleaning without arm fatigue.
For general household cleaning, the Eureka delivers superior performance across diverse surfaces and debris types. However, if your home is primarily hard floors with minimal carpeting, the BLACK+DECKER's performance is entirely adequate. The Eureka emerges as the winner for cleaning power, but the BLACK+DECKER remains competitive for specific use cases.
The BLACK+DECKER's 50-minute battery life is its strongest selling point, offering extended runtime that few competitors match at this price point. This runtime enables users to clean a 3,000-4,000 square foot home on a single charge, making it practical for larger apartments and small houses without mid-session recharging. The battery maintains consistent power delivery throughout the runtime, meaning suction doesn't diminish as the charge depletes.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro specifies a 20-minute runtime, which is significantly shorter and represents a notable limitation for this price point. A 20-minute runtime requires strategic planning for homes over 1,500 square feet and may necessitate recharging mid-session for thorough cleaning. However, users report that the actual runtime sometimes extends beyond 20 minutes on lower power settings, though this reduces suction effectiveness.
For practical household use, the BLACK+DECKER's 50-minute advantage is substantial and represents genuine value. Users can complete most residential cleaning tasks without recharging, making it more convenient for spontaneous cleanups and maintenance. The Eureka's shorter runtime isn't disqualifying for apartments or smaller homes but becomes frustrating in larger residences.
Battery charging time for both models is not specified, but cordless stick vacuums in this price range typically require 3-5 hours for full charge. The BLACK+DECKER's longer runtime means fewer charging cycles, potentially extending overall battery lifespan. For users prioritizing convenience and uninterrupted cleaning sessions, the BLACK+DECKER's battery advantage is significant and tangible.
The BLACK+DECKER wins decisively in battery life and runtime, offering more than double the cleaning time per charge. This advantage alone justifies the lower price point for many users and represents the most compelling reason to choose the BLACK+DECKER.
The BLACK+DECKER's 3.5-pound weight is exceptionally light, making it one of the most portable cordless vacuums available. This weight advantage translates directly to reduced arm fatigue during extended use, easier one-handed operation, and simplified stair cleaning. Users report being able to clean stairs, ceiling corners, and tight spaces without experiencing the fatigue that heavier models cause. The handheld format provides maximum flexibility for reaching under furniture and cleaning upholstered surfaces.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro, at 5.1 pounds, is still relatively lightweight but noticeably heavier than the BLACK+DECKER. This additional weight becomes apparent during extended use, particularly when cleaning stairs or holding the vacuum at awkward angles. However, 5.1 pounds remains manageable for most users and doesn't approach the fatigue issues associated with traditional upright vacuums.
Both models feature cordless stick designs that eliminate the tether constraint of corded vacuums, allowing complete freedom of movement throughout the home. The BLACK+DECKER's lighter weight makes it superior for extended handheld use, ceiling fan cleaning, and stair work. The Eureka's slightly heavier construction doesn't significantly impact usability for most cleaning tasks but may matter for users with physical limitations or those cleaning large homes regularly.
Dustbin emptying is straightforward on both models, with the BLACK+DECKER featuring a simple push-button mechanism. The Eureka's dustbin capacity isn't specified but likely similar to the BLACK+DECKER's. Frequent emptying is required with both models for extended cleaning sessions, which is typical for handheld-sized stick vacuums. Neither model offers the convenience of self-emptying or large-capacity bins found in premium models.
The BLACK+DECKER wins for portability and ease of use, particularly for users who prioritize lightweight design and minimal physical strain during cleaning.
Neither the BLACK+DECKER nor the Eureka RapidClean Pro offers smart features, app control, Wi-Fi connectivity, or advanced technology. Both are purely mechanical devices operated by manual power button and suction adjustment. This represents a significant difference from premium cordless vacuums that offer smartphone scheduling, performance monitoring, and filter maintenance alerts.
For most users, the absence of smart features is entirely acceptable and even preferable. Smart features add cost, complexity, and potential points of failure without dramatically improving cleaning performance. The BLACK+DECKER and Eureka focus resources on core cleaning functionality rather than technology bells and whistles. This approach results in lower prices and potentially greater long-term reliability.
Users who value simplicity and straightforward operation will appreciate both models' lack of complex technology. There's no app to download, no account to create, and no connectivity issues to troubleshoot. The vacuum simply operates when you press the power button, making these models accessible to users of all technical skill levels.
The absence of smart mapping and navigation features means neither model offers route optimization or coverage mapping. However, these features are primarily valuable for robot vacuums, not stick vacuums that require manual operation anyway. For stick vacuums, smart features provide minimal practical benefit.
Both models tie on smart features, which is appropriate given that both offer none. This equality actually favors budget-conscious buyers who don't need or want to pay for technology they won't use.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro is rated at 78 dB, which is moderately loud and comparable to typical cordless stick vacuums. For context, 78 dB is similar to a running dishwasher or heavy traffic noise. This volume makes the Eureka noticeable but not exceptionally loud compared to corded vacuums or robot models. The 250W brushless motor is the primary noise source, and 78 dB is reasonable for the suction power provided.
The BLACK+DECKER's noise level is not specified, but handheld-sized cordless vacuums with smaller motors typically operate at 70-75 dB. Users report the BLACK+DECKER is noticeably quieter than the Eureka, making it suitable for use during evening hours or in noise-sensitive environments. The lighter motor and smaller dustbin likely contribute to reduced vibration and noise.
For apartment dwellers or those with sleeping family members, the BLACK+DECKER's quieter operation is a meaningful advantage. The Eureka's 78 dB rating isn't prohibitively loud but may cause concern for users sensitive to noise or those cleaning during late hours. Neither model is exceptionally quiet compared to premium models, which can operate below 70 dB.
Noise perception is subjective, and some users find cordless vacuum noise acceptable while others find it annoying. The 3-8 dB difference between these models is perceptible but not dramatic. For most users, the noise difference is less important than cleaning performance, but for noise-sensitive households, the BLACK+DECKER's quieter operation is advantageous.
The BLACK+DECKER likely wins on noise level, though the Eureka's 78 dB rating remains acceptable for most households.
Both the BLACK+DECKER and Eureka feature dustbin designs rather than water tanks, making emptying straightforward and hygienic. The BLACK+DECKER's push-button dustbin emptying mechanism is simple and effective, allowing one-handed operation without touching dirt or debris. This design minimizes contact with dust and allergens, which is important for users with allergies or asthma.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro's dustbin capacity and emptying mechanism are not specified in detail, but cordless stick vacuums in this category typically feature similar button-release systems. Both models require regular emptying during extended cleaning sessions due to modest bin capacity. For apartment-sized homes or quick cleanups, emptying frequency is minimal. For larger homes, users may need to empty the bin 2-3 times during a complete cleaning.
Filter maintenance differs between models. The Eureka includes a washable filter, which is a significant advantage for long-term cost savings and environmental impact. Washable filters can be cleaned and reused indefinitely, whereas disposable filters require regular replacement. The BLACK+DECKER's filter type is not specified, but if disposable, users will incur ongoing replacement costs.
Regular filter maintenance is essential for both models to maintain suction performance. Clogged filters reduce suction efficiency and can damage the motor over time. Users should clean or replace filters monthly for regular use or more frequently for homes with pets or allergy sufferers. The Eureka's washable filter reduces maintenance costs compared to disposable alternatives.
The Eureka wins on long-term maintenance cost due to its washable filter, which saves money and reduces environmental impact over the vacuum's lifespan. However, the BLACK+DECKER's superior dustbin emptying mechanism provides a practical daily-use advantage.
The BLACK+DECKER Carpet Sweeper comes with a basic cordless stick design and dustbin. Specific included accessories are not detailed, but handheld-sized cordless vacuums in this category typically include a crevice tool and upholstery brush. These basic accessories enable cleaning of stairs, upholstered furniture, and tight spaces, expanding the vacuum's versatility beyond floor cleaning.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro includes a motorized brush tool, which is a significant advantage over the BLACK+DECKER. The motorized brush actively agitates carpet fibers, dramatically improving cleaning performance on carpeted surfaces. This tool is valued at $50-100 if purchased separately, making its inclusion substantial added value. The Eureka also features an LED headlight, which improves visibility in dark corners and under furniture.
The motorized brush tool is genuinely useful and represents one of the Eureka's strongest advantages. It transforms the vacuum's carpet cleaning capability and justifies the higher price point for users with significant carpeting. The LED headlight is a nice convenience feature that improves usability in dimly lit areas.
The BLACK+DECKER's accessory package is less impressive, focusing on basic tools rather than motorized attachments. However, for users with primarily hard floors, the included accessories may be entirely adequate. The simpler accessory approach also contributes to the BLACK+DECKER's lower price and lighter weight.
The Eureka wins on included accessories, particularly the motorized brush tool, which provides tangible cleaning performance improvements. However, the BLACK+DECKER's basic accessories are sufficient for its intended use cases.
The BLACK+DECKER Carpet Sweeper at $54.99 is exceptionally affordable, representing one of the lowest prices for cordless stick vacuums. This price point makes it accessible to budget-conscious consumers and those seeking a supplementary cleaning tool without significant investment. For the price, the 50-minute runtime and lightweight design deliver genuine value. Users are essentially paying $1.10 per minute of runtime, which is competitive.
The Eureka RapidClean Pro at $136.99 is 2.5 times more expensive than the BLACK+DECKER, representing a significant investment. However, the additional cost brings the 250W motor, motorized brush tool, and LED headlight. For users with carpeted homes, the motorized brush alone justifies the price increase. The Eureka's stronger suction and accessories position it as a capable primary vacuum rather than a supplementary tool.
Value assessment depends on intended use. For apartment dwellers with hard floors, the BLACK+DECKER offers exceptional value, delivering adequate cleaning performance at minimal cost. For homeowners with mixed flooring and moderate carpeting, the Eureka's additional features and power justify the higher price. Neither model offers the warranty or durability guarantees of premium brands, so long-term reliability is uncertain.
The BLACK+DECKER's $54.99 price is difficult to beat for basic cordless cleaning. At this price, even if the vacuum fails after two years, the cost-per-use is minimal. The Eureka's $136.99 price requires more confidence in durability and satisfaction with performance. Neither model specifies warranty coverage, which is a concern when making a purchasing decision.
For budget-conscious buyers, the BLACK+DECKER offers exceptional value and represents one of the best cordless vacuum bargains available. For those willing to spend more for enhanced performance, the Eureka delivers better cleaning power and more versatile accessories. The BLACK+DECKER wins on price, while the Eureka wins on performance-per-dollar for users with carpeted homes.
Pet owners generate substantial amounts of hair and dander requiring powerful suction and motorized brush action. The Eureka RapidClean Pro's 250W motor and motorized brush tool excel at extracting embedded pet hair from carpets and upholstered furniture. The stronger suction captures airborne pet dander more effectively, which is important for allergy management. For homes with multiple pets or shedding breeds, the Eureka's cleaning power is essential.
The BLACK+DECKER's lighter suction struggles with heavy pet hair accumulation and deep carpet embedding. Pet owners would find themselves making multiple passes or missing hair entirely, leading to frustration and inadequate results. The Eureka's motorized brush specifically targets pet hair, making it the clear choice for pet-heavy households.
Large homes require extended runtime to complete cleaning without mid-session recharging. The BLACK+DECKER's 50-minute battery life enables cleaning of 3,000-4,000 square foot homes on a single charge, making it practical for larger residences. The Eureka's 20-minute runtime would require recharging multiple times for large homes, which is inconvenient and time-consuming.
For homeowners with 4,000+ square feet, the BLACK+DECKER's runtime advantage is substantial and practical. Users can complete cleaning without interruption, improving efficiency and convenience. The Eureka's shorter runtime is a significant limitation for large homes, despite its stronger suction.
Allergy sufferers benefit from powerful suction that captures fine dust, pollen, and dander. The Eureka's 250W motor provides stronger suction for more complete allergen removal. The washable filter is particularly valuable, allowing thorough cleaning without replacing disposable filters that may leak particles during installation. The motorized brush agitates surfaces more completely, dislodging allergens that lighter suction misses.
The BLACK+DECKER's lighter suction may not capture all fine allergens, and its filter type is unspecified. For users with significant allergies, the Eureka's more powerful and thorough cleaning is worth the additional cost.
The BLACK+DECKER's $54.99 price is unbeatable for budget-conscious consumers. This price point makes cordless cleaning accessible to those who couldn't justify higher investments. For apartment dwellers or those seeking supplementary cleaning tools, the BLACK+DECKER delivers adequate performance at minimal cost. The extended runtime provides genuine practical value without premium pricing.
Budget constraints often dictate purchasing decisions, and the BLACK+DECKER removes price as a barrier to cordless cleaning. Even if durability is limited, the low cost means minimal financial loss if the vacuum fails.
Tech enthusiasts seeking smart features, app control, or advanced technology will be disappointed by both models. Neither offers Wi-Fi connectivity, smartphone control, or intelligent mapping. Both are purely mechanical devices without technological sophistication. Tech-focused buyers should consider premium models like the Samsung Jet or Dyson V15, which offer app integration and advanced sensors.
Winner: Eureka RapidClean Pro Cordless Vacuum
The Eureka RapidClean Pro emerges as the superior overall choice despite its higher price point. The 250W brushless motor delivers cleaning performance that the BLACK+DECKER cannot match, particularly on carpeted surfaces and for pet hair removal. The included motorized brush tool is a game-changer that justifies the additional investment, providing suction enhancement that makes the Eureka a capable primary vacuum rather than a supplementary tool.
The Eureka's washable filter provides long-term cost savings and environmental benefits compared to disposable alternatives. The LED headlight adds practical value for cleaning dark spaces. While the 20-minute runtime is shorter than ideal, it remains adequate for most households when combined with the Eureka's superior cleaning power. Users can clean more thoroughly in 20 minutes with the Eureka than they can in 50 minutes with the BLACK+DECKER, making the shorter runtime less problematic.
For most households, the Eureka's performance advantages justify its $82 premium over the BLACK+DECKER. The motorized brush alone makes the Eureka substantially more effective on carpets, which are present in most homes. The stronger suction captures pet hair and allergens more completely, improving home cleanliness and air quality.
However, the BLACK+DECKER remains an excellent choice for specific situations. Apartment dwellers with primarily hard floors will find the BLACK+DECKER's 50-minute runtime and lightweight design perfectly adequate. Budget-conscious buyers who cannot justify the Eureka's price will appreciate the BLACK+DECKER's affordability and solid basic performance. Users prioritizing portability and minimal arm fatigue will prefer the BLACK+DECKER's 3.5-pound weight.
For pet owners, allergy sufferers, and those with significant carpeting, the Eureka RapidClean Pro is the clear winner. For budget-conscious apartment dwellers with hard floors, the BLACK+DECKER represents exceptional value. Most homeowners seeking a capable cordless stick vacuum should choose the Eureka for its superior cleaning performance and versatile accessories.
